Studio Barbara Antonini
Back to blog
Tax·November 5, 2026·4 min read

Conventional Remuneration and Aviation Personnel: Case Law Rejects Application by Analogy

The conventional remuneration regime for employees working abroad represents one of the most significant tax benefits available to taxpayers residing in Italy who carry out their employment activities outside the country. However, recent case law has confirmed that the absence of a specific job classification in the relevant annual Ministerial Table entirely precludes the application of this preferential tax regime, thereby placing certain professional categories, such as airline pilots, at a disadvantage.

by Barbara Antonini

retrib personale volo

What Is the Conventional Remuneration Regime?

The mechanism provided for under Article 51(8-bis) of the Italian Consolidated Income Tax Act (TUIR) allows income tax to be calculated on a notional (conventional) taxable income basis rather than on the actual salary received.

This provision applies to employees who, while retaining their tax residence in Italy, work abroad on a continuous basis and as the exclusive subject of their employment relationship for more than 183 days over a twelve-month period. Tax is calculated on the basis of remuneration tables established annually by specific Ministerial Decree, thereby reducing the overall tax burden.

The Issue with the Ministerial Table: The Case of Airline Pilots

If a profession or sector is not expressly included in the Ministerial Decree, according to the Italian Revenue Agency and a recent court ruling, the taxpayer cannot claim the preferential tax regime.

The Ministry of Labour and the Ministry of Economy and Finance identify each year the economic sectors and professional categories eligible for this tax benefit. Major categories within the aviation industry, such as airline pilots and captains who work on a permanent basis for foreign carriers, are systematically excluded from this detailed list. This creates a protection gap for flight crew members, who are forced to contend with the strict interpretations adopted by the Italian Tax Authorities.

The Prohibition on Application by Analogy and Tax Discrimination

According to the restrictive interpretation, preferential taxation is an exceptional provision and cannot be extended by analogy to categories that are not expressly covered.

The key issue concerns the potential discriminatory treatment of employees resulting from the prohibition on applying the conventional remuneration tables by analogy. Since pilots cannot be treated as equivalent to employees in comparable sectors (such as land transport or industrial management), aviation personnel are subject to unequal treatment: despite spending and working the same number of days abroad, they are required to declare and pay tax in Italy on their entire actual income, without benefiting from the flat-rate tax treatment available to other cross-border workers or employees on international assignments.

Confirmation by the Courts: Judgment No. 53 of 2026 of the Provincial Tax Court of Pavia

The First-Instance Tax Court of Pavia, in Judgment No. 53 of 2026, ruled that the absence of the relevant contractual position from the Ministerial Table categorically precludes access to the conventional remuneration calculation method.

The judges clarified that, since this is a tax relief provision and therefore an exceptional rule, recourse to analogy to fill the gap is not legally permissible. Applying this interpretation to flight crew members, if the Ministry has not included their professional category in the tables, taxpayers cannot simply assign themselves the remuneration benchmark applicable to another sector.

Practical Example

An airline pilot resident in Italy who flies for a European airline for 200 days a year cannot apply the conventional remuneration parameters.

Even if the pilot meets the 183-day requirement, the absence of the specific job classification "aircrew personnel" in the Ministerial Table, together with the prohibition on application by analogy reaffirmed by the Pavia judgment, will require the pilot to pay tax in Italy on the full amount of the foreign salary actually received, without any flat-rate reduction of the taxable income.

5. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Based on the Pavia judgment, can a pilot classify their role as equivalent to that of a senior executive?

No. The Pavia Tax Court expressly ruled out this possibility, establishing that conventional remuneration cannot be applied by analogy where the relevant professional classification is missing from the Ministerial Table.

Does the exclusion of pilots from the tables amount to unfair discrimination? Can an appeal be based on constitutional principles of equality?

Yes. The exclusion creates an apparent disparity in treatment between employees who are in essentially the same factual circumstances (working abroad on a permanent basis for more than 183 days).

When challenging tax assessments issued by the Italian Tax Authorities, taxpayers may raise the issue of the constitutional legitimacy of Article 51(8-bis) of the TUIR on the grounds that it violates Articles 3 (the principle of equality) and 53 (the principle of ability to pay) of the Italian Constitution. They may ask the Tax Court to refer the matter to the Italian Constitutional Court, seeking a declaration that the provision is unconstitutional insofar as it unreasonably discriminates against flight crew members compared with other professional categories.

What tax protections remain available to aviation personnel who regularly work abroad?

In the absence of conventional remuneration, it remains essential to examine the double taxation agreements between Italy and the country in which the airline is based, as well as the correct application of the foreign tax credit for taxes already paid abroad.

For a more comprehensive overview, read our guide to the taxation of flight crew operating in international air traffic.

Our firm provides tax advisory services to pilots and flight crew members.

No liability can be attributed for the use of the information contained in this blog.

Looking for a reliable accountant?

Let's talk, no strings attached.

A first conversation to understand your situation, assess your needs and explore how we can help.